Friday, October 29, 2010
Two New York Times stories on faulty Halliburton cement supplies to BP
Thursday, October 28, 2010
Juan Williams: the facts, please
Wednesday, October 27, 2010
Michael Moore's Response to Juan Williams
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/michael-moore/juan-williams-is-right-po_b_772766.html
ON JUAN WILLIAMS
I don’t know if it is appropriate to for Juan Williams to play different roles on NPR and on FOX NEWS. On NPR , Juan Williams, was more tamed. A measured commentator, but on FOX NEW is he is more daring and edgy.
Juan Williams was playing to opposite spectrums. I don’t think Juan Williams is the problem. The media is the problem. The media is the problem because it has a problem. The problem being that it has to entertain and each outlet has to compete for attention. Unfortunately, it’s not easy to get attention with good stories and reporting. These days in order to get attention one needs a little controversy is needed.
Lede with descriptive verbs
Tuesday, October 26, 2010
Internet Privacy and Harrasment Case Discussed
Monday, October 25, 2010
National Journal is Retooling
Remember the BP Oil Spill?
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/10/25/AR2010102500869.html
BP CEO Bob Dudley addressed a lobbyist group in London today. His speech centered on rebuilding the company's image in the United States.
Above are two links to coverage of the story. The first is from the BBC; the second from AP. I found it interesting that one story is straight business coverage targeted toward a UK audience, while the other is meant for U.S. readers and takes in a lot more cultural controversy.
Wednesday, October 20, 2010
Great Story with Direct Lede
$18 Million to Man Wrongly Imprisoned
Anita Hill V. Clarence Thomas...19 years later.
The CNN one focuses on the 1991 case and reignites the feud between Hill and Thomas.
The Yahoo! AP story focuses on the phone call itself, the strange timing of it and Hill's aversion to the press.
Finally, the Christian Science Monitor gives an inordinate amount of attention to Virginia Thomas and her political pursuits, which seem to nearly overshadow the harassment issue or even the phone call to Hill.
Tuesday, October 19, 2010
What is the news media forgot to report the facts?
Monday, October 18, 2010
SLAMMER
http://www.slammernews.com/palm_beach_co_fl.htm
The link is to the Palm Beach edition. The edition I saw was the Broward County edition. The cover stated “first issue. COLLECTIBLE!” I bought a copy for a $1.00 just because it struck me. The publication has arrest pictures plastered all over its first page and all throughout the publication.
The rationale is that this ok to do because the pictures are public record. I don’t think it’s fair to someone arrested for possessing less than 20 ounces of cannabis or a DUI or any misdemeanor. Some of the people on the cover where arrested for driving with a suspended license. Let me tell you, in Florida you can get your license suspended for anything.
I guess the point is that just because something is public record doesn’t mean that it should be used for publication purposes. Journalist should be responsible and try to avoid embarrassing someone if possible. I see no justification for publishing a picture of 17-year-old who was arrested for driving with a suspended license. We don’t know if this individual is guilty and publishing their picture in a weekly publication amounts to a sort of punishment. In fact, a punishment which could be harsher than any imposed by a court.
An example, a person could be arrested for possession of cannabis and then found to be not guilty. Meanwhile, the person’s boss sees the picture and fires him/her.
It could be argued that newspapers publish suspect’s names before there is a determination as to their guilt. However, most of the crimes reported in regular media tend to be about more substantial crimes like murder, manslaughter, drug trafficking, etc.
Media-mania
Sunday, October 17, 2010
a fearless story!
Details about Mr. Headley like: "But at night he loved watching “Seinfeld” and Jay Leno;" and giving the sense of place as we were talking about in last class in: "Sipping tea in a cafe overlooking a plaza in Morocco, Ms. Outalha said that in hindsight, she is convinced that he is both men." add a lot of life to the otherwise morose story.
Example of a focused profile
Shortly after last week's class, I saw a terrific piece on Ralph Lauren and his new store in Manhattan in the New York Times.
Jam-packed with visuals through words.
Wednesday, October 13, 2010
An excellent color story
The story focuses on restaurant patrons in a New York Restaurant-Row Chilean bistro as they watch and celebrate the rescues.
I personally was charmed by the story because of its simplicity -- this isn't the usual NYT heavy, serious fare, which, don't get me wrong, I do respect. But every now and then, I enjoy a story that is easily informative and cheers on the soul. Simply.
Here in Pittsburgh, where a similar rescue took place a few years ago (Quecreek in Somerset, Pa.), we've had color stories on workers who were deployed to help in Chile because of their experience; we've been given detailed stories about the equipment and medical procedures that are needed to bring the trapped men back to the surface. All good.
But there is something special about regular people celebrating a miracle.
See what social networking did- created news!
Tuesday, October 12, 2010
Good Lede, Hot Button Story That Presents More Questions Than Answers
We've discussed bias in this class and how successful some journalists are in removing their own bias from a story to allow the viewers to come to their own opinions. I'm not sure if this reporter did that completely but she did bring up a few quotes and "Twitter" messages from the accused student that I found to be interesting. In many of the articles I've read online or seen on television, it's talked about the events that happened after the streaming of the encounter on the webcam but not the events before or from Ravi's perspective of what motivated him to do this. Lisa Foderaro shows that in the Tweets Dharun Ravi made about Clementi's actions in their dorm room, there was some obvious tension between them and there was some reoccurring pattern in conflict. The quotes from the defendant are indicative that the author does believe there was conflict and while perhaps prejudice from Ravi, the extent of it being called a "hate crime" are in some question. I do think Foderaro does have clear bias towards the fact that Ravi is guilty by use of the quotes she uses such as one made by gay rights groups like this "Steven Goldstein, chairman of the gay rights group Garden State Equality, said Wednesday that he considered the death a hate crime. “We are sickened that anyone in our society, such as the students allegedly responsible for making the surreptitious video, might consider destroying others’ lives as a sport,” he said in a statement. ". She does show that Clementi was unknown by most students and that there were no prior incidents of violence, verbal abuse, or anything else from Ravi or any other student. I found this article interesting because I was left with more questions than answers about the boy who broadcast the encounter Clementi had in their room and I have more questions about Clementi himself. How he was perceived by others, his family, what conflicts he and Ravi had besides this. This articles does make me see that the incident isn't as black and white as it seems.
Obviously another important thing to note about this article is that facts about this story were and are still unfolding, so the reporter was writing based on the information she had and based on the interviews with people she encountered at the time. This hot-button topic and story will produce many more interesting angles.
Sunday, October 10, 2010
Brilliant Human Interest Story!!!
Here is the link:
"Above and Beyond" by Wright Thompson
I really recommend this to anyone that has time!
FYI...If everything goes according to plan, the miners might get to evacuate on Wednesday, October 13th.
Thursday, October 7, 2010
Not local by a long shot
Wednesday, October 6, 2010
The art of showing and not telling
Heinz's prose is almost bare-bones. Color is added by quotes from various characters around the track. Consider the lede:
"They were going to the post for the sixth race at Jamaica, two year olds, some making their first starts, to go five and a half furlongs for a purse of four thousand dollars. They were moving slowly down the backstretch toward the gate, some of them cantering, others walking, and in the press box they had stopped their working or their kidding to watch, most of them interested in one horse.
"Air Lift," Jim Roach said. "Full brother of Assault."
Assault, who won the triple crown ... making this one too, by Bold Venture, himself a Derby winner, out of Igual, herself by the great Equipoise ... Great names in the breeding line ... and now the little guy making his first start, perhaps the start of another great career."
It's remarkable how easily he builds tension and creates a sense of scope. It soon all comes crashing down for Air Lift:
"They were off well, although Air Lift was fifth. They were moving toward the first turn, and now Air Lift was fourth. They were going into the turn, and now Air Lift was starting to go, third perhaps, when suddenly he slowed, a horse stopping, and below in the stands you could hear a sudden cry, as the rest left him, still trying to run but limping, his jockey -- Dave Gorman -- half falling, half sliding off.
"He broke a leg!" somebody, holding binoculars to his eyes, shouted in the press box. "He broke a leg!""
The entire piece is like this. No telling the audience what to feel. Prose that describes and little more. Very spare use of adjectives and adverbs. I'd like to write about the end, but I don't want to spoil it. I'll just say that it's some of the most haunting writing I've ever read. of course, not once does Heinz tell me that the scene is haunting.
Read the article here: http://www.gangrey.com/66
How Local is Local
Today, another article popped up about the same wind turbine dust-up on Vinalhaven. But this time the story ran bottom of the fold, front-page, of The New York Times. (link to article follows: For those Near the Miserable Hum of Clean Energy....http://www.nytimes.com/2010/10/06/business/energy-environment/06noise.html). According to The New York Times, not only have noise complaints emminated from little Vinalhaven in Penobscott Bay, but also in Illinois, Texas, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin and Massachusetts, among other states. Beyond our borders, complaints have arisen in Canada and Great Britain. Perhaps the Lindgren's are not so cranky after all.
But I have my own personal crank with the issue: Why didn't the Globe put this story in context? Why didn't they give it any teeth? It makes a difference if an incident is a one-off or if there is evidence of the same phenomenon occurring in other places.
Like Molly's complaint about the Boston-based MacArthur genius grant story, the Globe once again failed to put the wind turbine news piece in a wider context. Yes, there is a local angle to both the wind turbine and MacArthur grant recipient stories, but imagine how much richer and more meaty each of the stories would have been if our local news makers were put in the context of the big picture, where they belong.
A colorful lede
In a blustery and vigorous first debate, gubernatorial candidates Meg Whitman and Jerry Brown dueled Tuesday over their differing solutions to California's dire problems, with Whitman slighting Brown as a tool of labor unions and Brown excoriating her as a billionaire running for office to benefit the rich.
From start to finish, the one-hour debate was a distillation of the months of the general election race, its tone set by an early question about how each would grapple with the state's $19-billion budget deficit. After Democrat Brown said he would bring all parties together, Republican Whitman seized on his vow.
You can read the full story here: http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-governor-debate-20100929,0,3751700.story
Using addresses of the accused in stories
Check it out here: http://www.goupstate.com/article/20100921/ARTICLES/9211025/1051?tc=ar
It struck me as odd that the address would be used, especially in something that involves a "sex with a minor" charge. I brought this up to Jeremy and he mentioned that this is standard practice, but there are certain cases where they wouldn't do this (dometic violence cases, etc...)
What do you all think of reporting the home address of the accused person in a story? The information that is reported is public information and is available to everyone...but is it too invasive? Do people have a right to know?
It's not so simple
Take for example an incident I just noticed this morning:
On NBC's "Today" show, an anchor was interviewing a woman and her mother; the woman allegedly witnessed her husband's murder on a lake that is both part of the U.S. and Mexico. The anchor asked the woman's mother if she was disturbed that the "voracity" of her daughter's story was questioned.
"Voracity"? Really?
Why not just use the word truthfulness?
This is especially ironic as morning television shows cater to a wide audience, not a niche vocabulary-steeped group.
Sunday, October 3, 2010
Oh, come on, Boston Globe
One story, hair-raising in its implications, handled differently in two newspapers makes for a good writing lesson.
Friday, October 1, 2010
An interesting Lede
"By the time the bullets slammed into the Tripod Collision & Repair Shop's concrete walls — thwack, thwack, thwack — Gibson Junior Belizaire had nowhere left to run."
On a previous blog I analyzed another article by the same author and came to the conclusion that voice overshadowed content. However, The same cannot be said of this piece. This piece paints a picture of Miami that is real and yet distant. I dont know how many times I drove through overtown as if it didnt exist. As if the only thing that existed was my car and the pavement.
This piece gets me out of the car and paints the sad yet fascinating streets of overtown with another hue.
The Lede is great because it starts with action in the middle of the story. The sound effects although tacky create an atmosphere and pace.
Another sentence that caught my is the following:
"The muddy yard flashed red and blue in the swaying, early-afternoon police lights."
This sentence may be a bit poetic, but it works fine in the piece. The point is to write a story that is informative, enlightning, and entertaining. Below is the link
http://www.miaminewtimes.com/2010-09-23/news/gibson-belizaire-victim-or-criminal/